In the mid-80's, Jack Starr was on his way out of Virgin Steele and making a mess of things. David DeFeis, co-songwriter, wanted to do some of his own work, and he ended up writing albums for a few other bands (Piledriver and Original Sin being the most notable). But Dave didn't stop at just writing - he actually formed a side-project with the current members of VS, but replaced Jack Starr with Edward Pursino, who would later become the band's permanent guitarist. Rather than continuing on Virgin Steele's path, the band decided to make a much different album...Despite everything you will hear on this album, it is indeed true that the Noble Savage line-up of VS are the people playing it. Exorcist is not a power metal band. Instead, Nightmare Theatre sounds more like a cleaner Venom, or a less-thrashy version of Slayer's debut. And David does an excellent job on the writing here. It's not new or progressive in any way, but it is really fucking good speed metal. About the only thing that brings it down is a few random interludes or spoken parts that just feel off. Some are even hilarious (intentionally, I hope). It's not that far off to imagine that this album was written and recorded drunk. But it doesn't hamper the performance at all. David covers a wide range of styles, going from death growls in the first song to black metal shrieks in others. All of his vocals are pretty distorted, but it works well for the music. Undoubtedly, though, the best part of the album is EDWARD FUCKING PURSINO! Holy shit, if you couldn't tell from his work in Virgin Steele, this man is an awesome guitarist. His solos in this album will make you want to grow a cunt, just so it can be ripped out. You definitely need this album - if not just for the novelty, it stands strong on its own merits.
Nightmare Theatre (1985)








































